I Scold My Kids and I Feel Bad: The Science of Making It Right

I Scold My Kids and I Feel Bad: The Science of Making It Right

Editorial Team

Wednesday, 20 August 2025

TL;DR for Busy Parents

  • You're not a bad parent. Feeling guilty means your conscience works.

  • Occasional yelling won't traumatize your child - it's the pattern that matters, not one bad moment.

  • The repair is more important than the rupture. What you do next can actually strengthen your relationship.

  • Use 4-Step Emergency Repair Kit expained below

Getting your four-year-old to put on shoes is like negotiating a peace treaty between two countries that speak different languages, where one side's primary diplomatic strategy is lying on the floor screaming about the "wrong socks" (and yes, both socks are identical). You'd think having a fully developed brain would give you the advantage, but apparently nothing could have prepared us for the psychological warfare that is Tuesday morning shoe time.

So there you are, already late for work, coffee getting cold, and suddenly you hear that voice coming out of your mouth, the one that sounds suspiciously like your own mother (or father) when she was at her wit's end. "JUST PUT ON THE SHOES!" you yell, immediately followed by that familiar sinking feeling in your stomach. Great. You've become that parent.

Welcome to the club nobody wants to join: Parents Who Yell and Feel Terrible About It.

The Guilt is Real (And So is the Science)

Let's get one thing straight, feeling bad after yelling at your kids isn't just normal, it's actually a sign that you're a good parent. That guilt is an internal signal that you must take action, according to family therapist Meri Wallace. It means your conscience is working just fine, thank you very much.

But here's what's fascinating: research on rupture-repair cycles shows that relationships can actually get stronger after conflict if we know how to repair them properly. This doesn't mean yelling is good for relationships, but rather that when conflicts inevitably happen, the repair process can become a teaching moment.

Important distinction: We're not talking about yelling being beneficial. We're talking about what happens after we mess up. Consistent scoldings make a child feel humiliated, fearful, guilty, ashamed, anxious, and stressed. There's no therapeutic value in the yelling itself. The value is in learning how to repair when things go wrong.

Why We Lose Our Cool (Spoiler: It's Not Really About the Shoes)

The short answer is because we feel overwhelmed or angry, which makes us raise our voices. But let's dig deeper, because understanding why we snap is the first step toward snapping less often.

Parental overwhelm is like a smartphone battery. It starts the day at 100%, but by 3 PM you're desperately looking for a charger while your phone dies at the worst possible moment. Except in parenting, that moment is usually when your toddler decides the grocery store floor is the perfect place for an interpretive dance about crackers.

Malaysian parents face unique pressures too. We're juggling traditional expectations from extended family ("Why isn't little Ahmad speaking Mandarin yet?"), modern parenting advice from Instagram, and our own childhood experiences (which may or may not have involved significantly more yelling than today's gentle parenting gurus recommend).

When we're stressed, tired, or emotionally triggered, our prefrontal cortex—the part responsible for rational decision-making—basically goes offline. What's left is our emotional brain, which has all the sophistication of a fire alarm: LOUD, URGENT, NOT PARTICULARLY HELPFUL.

The Real Impact: What Science Says About Yelling

Before we dive into solutions, let's acknowledge the research honestly. A study by Suffren et al. at Université de Montréal found that children exposed to harsh parenting practices (including yelling, hitting, and shaking) between ages 2-9 showed smaller brain structures in areas linked to emotions, memory, and stress response when they reached their teens.

Here's the crucial nuance that often gets lost: This research studied "harsh parenting practices" as a pattern, not isolated incidents of raised voices. The difference between occasional yelling in an otherwise warm, supportive relationship and consistent harsh treatment is enormous, like the difference between getting caught in one rainstorm versus living in a flood zone.

Think of it like this: Having one small argument occasionally is very different from constant conflict every day. Context, frequency, and what happens afterward all matter enormously.

What crosses the line:

  • Never insult, name-call, demean, or threaten the safety of a child

  • Yelling that happens multiple times per week or becomes the default communication style

  • Using harsh words that amount to emotional abuse

  • When yelling is paired with physical intimidation or aggression

What's in the realm of normal human parenting:

  • The occasional raised voice when you've asked several times for cooperation

  • Getting loud when safety is involved ("DON'T RUN IN THE PARKING LOT!")

  • Losing your cool during particularly stressful moments (less than once per week)

When to seek professional help:

  • If you're yelling multiple times per week

  • If you notice your child becoming withdrawn, anxious, or aggressive

  • If you feel consistently out of control with your emotions

  • If you had trauma in your own childhood that's affecting your parenting

The Art of the Repair: How to Fix What Feels Broken

Here's where things get interesting. Research on attachment theory shows us that relationships can actually get stronger after conflict, if we know how to repair them properly. The rupture to repair cycle isn't just about damage control; it's about modeling for our children how healthy relationships handle conflict.

Step 1: Cool Your Jets First

The first step to making a repair with your child is to be able to calm your own body. This is like the airplane oxygen mask rule (you can't help anyone else breathe if you're gasping for air yourself).

If you are living in a tense triggered space in that moment, that is the energy our child will receive and we won't be able to repair. So before you do anything else, take a few minutes to get your nervous system back online.

This might look like:

  • Stepping into another room and taking deep breaths

  • Telling your child, "I need a minute to calm down. I'll be right back."

  • Doing something physical to discharge the stress (even just shaking your hands out)

Step 2: Own Your Part (Without Drowning in Shame)

This step is important! Some parents think apologizing undermines their authority, but actually the opposite is true. When you model accountability, you're teaching your child one of life's most important skills.

Your apology doesn't need to be a dissertation on your failures as a human being. Something simple works: "I'm sorry I yelled. That wasn't the right way to handle my frustration. You didn't deserve that."

Notice what this apology doesn't include: excuses, blame-shifting, or dramatic self-flagellation. You're not saying, "I'm a terrible parent" or "You made me so angry." You're taking responsibility for your actions while maintaining your role as the adult.

Step 3: Reconnect Before You Redirect

Affection is powerful. It has the ability to melt away negative feelings instantaneously when offered genuinely. This doesn't mean you ignore whatever issue triggered the whole mess, but you prioritize connection over correction.

A hug, sitting down to your child's eye level, or even just a gentle tone can signal safety. Remember, their little nervous system just experienced a threat (even if you didn't mean it that way), so they need to feel safe before they can learn anything.

Step 4: Problem-Solve Together

Once you apologize, talk over the situation with your child and explore alternative ways you both could have interacted. This turns the whole experience into a collaborative learning opportunity.

"What do you think we could do differently next time when Mama asks you to put on your shoes?"

"How do you think Mama could ask in a way that would help you listen better?"

This isn't about making your four-year-old responsible for managing your emotions (they're four, not tiny therapists). It's about showing them that relationships involve two people, and both can contribute to making things better.

The Malaysian Context: Culture, Family, and Guilt

In Malaysian culture, where respect for elders and family harmony are deeply valued, parental guilt can feel especially heavy. Many of us grew up with stricter discipline and worry we're either being too harsh (like our parents) or too lenient (unlike our parents).

The truth is, you can honor your cultural values while also embracing what modern psychology teaches us about healthy development. Cross-cultural attachment research has found that three key principles hold true across different cultures: secure attachment is the most common and most valued pattern globally; maternal sensitivity influences how children form attachments; and secure early attachments predict better social and emotional outcomes later in life.

This means that the fundamental human need for secure, responsive relationships transcends cultural differences. Whether your family speaks Bahasa Malaysia, Mandarin, Tamil, or English at home, your child needs to know they're loved, valued, and safe with you.

Breaking the Cycle: Practical Strategies for Less Yelling

The "Pause and Name" Strategy

When you feel the yell building up, try this: "I'm feeling really frustrated right now. I need to take a breath before I say something I'll regret." This does two things: it gives you a moment to reset, and it models emotional awareness for your child.

The "Broken Record" Technique

Instead of escalating volume, try escalating clarity. "Shoes on, please." (Wait 30 seconds.) "Shoes on, please." (Wait 30 seconds.) "I can see you're having trouble with your shoes. Let me help you."

The "Natural Consequences" Approach

Sometimes the best response to shoe resistance is, "Okay, we'll bring the shoes in the car and you can put them on when we get there." (Revolutionary, I know, but picking your battles is a legitimate parenting strategy.)

When Professional Help Makes Sense

Seek family counseling or support if:

  • You're yelling multiple times per week despite trying other strategies

  • Your child shows signs of anxiety, withdrawal, or increased aggression

  • You feel consistently overwhelmed or out of control

  • You have your own history of childhood trauma affecting your parenting

  • Your partner or family members express concern about your anger patterns

This isn't about being a "bad parent". It's about being a parent who cares enough to get support when needed. Just like you'd see a doctor for a persistent cough, sometimes our emotional and relational health needs professional attention.

Round It Up: The Bottom Line

Here's what you need to remember: all humans lose their patience sometimes, and occasional conflict is normal in relationships. The goal isn't to become a perfect parent (spoiler alert: they don't exist). The goal is to create overall patterns of warmth, responsiveness, and repair when things go wrong.

Important reminders:

  • Every child is different, some are more sensitive to raised voices than others

  • If you're yelling more than occasionally (less than once per week), seek support

  • The repair process is what builds resilience, not the conflict itself

  • Your overall relationship pattern matters more than individual moments

Conflict happens in all relationships. The key is learning how to lead the repair process and building overall security in your relationship with your child.

Your kids don't need a perfect parent. They need a real one who cares enough to keep trying, growing, and apologizing when necessary. And honestly? That's exactly what you're already doing.

Try StoryTime Free for 7 Days!

Try StoryTime Free for 7 Days!

Try StoryTime Free for 7 Days!

StoryTime brings fun, creative and educational activities to curious minds aged 3-7

  1. Expert-designed activities

  2. Safe, ad-free digital space

  3. Foster creativity, critical thinking and storytelling